你在我门外留了张单子 This list you left outside my door...
第一条 把克莱德还给华生 Item 1, return Clyde to Watson.
他周末陪我 I enjoy his company on the weekends;
其他时间得陪着她 she has him during the week.
我不关心你们如何分割对乌龟的抚养权 I don't care how you divide up your turtle.
我关心的是 你让我把他带去切尔西 I care that you're asking me to take him to Chelsea.
如果你记得 我们协议中有一条 Part of our arrangement, you will recall,
就是在我忙碌的时候你得协助我完成日常事务 is that you assist with quotidian matters when I'm busy.
"忙碌" 你现在可是在看乌龟吃生菜 "Busy?" You're watching a turtle eat lettuce.
我在进行一项医学研究 I'm conducting medical research.
记得吗 我们解剖那具尸体时 Remember, I cut my hand
我可是划伤了我的手 while we were dissecting that cadaver?
现在我正在治疗伤口 I'm tending to the wound as we speak.
另外我也在展现 I'm also demonstrating that
蚂蝗能够加速修复受损组织 leeches can be useful in accelerating
这一功用 the repair of damaged tissue.
太恶心了 你在给自己放血 That is disgusting. You're bleeding yourself.
而你对这些生物 And you are perpetuating a long-held prejudice
一贯持有很深的偏见 against these creatures.
随你便 If you say so.
我不会带你的乌龟上地铁的 I'm still not taking your turtle on the subway.
如果电话是找我的 就得等几分钟 If that's for me, I’m going to need a few minutes.
我现在有点头晕 I'm feeling a bit faint.
抱歉 我在楼上的时候有点心不在焉 So, sorry, I was a bit distracted upstairs.
没记住你的名字 I didn't catch your name.
埃德温·波斯坦 Edwin Borstein.
我伦敦有个朋友曾雇佣过你 I have a friend from London who's used you before.
他说你很出色 He said you're excellent.
而且小心谨慎 And discreet.
你为什么需要我小心谨慎呢 Why have you need of my discretion?
我有一家软件公司 I run a software company.
我们专做AI应用 We specialize in AI applications.
我猜你知道 I assume you know that
那是人工智能的意思 that stands for "Artificial intelligence."
是 我对这个领域很熟悉 Yes, I'm well-acquainted with the field.
几天前的一个晚上 有人闯入了我们的实验室 A couple of nights ago, someone broke into our lab.
他们拷贝了我们正在开发的一个软件 They made a copy of a program that we've been working on.
我将电脑设定为每次启动时 I rigged the computer to take a photo
都会拍一张照片 every time it's booted up,
以防这类事件发生 just in case something like this happened.
所以 我手头有张照片 So I have a picture.
算是照片吧 Kind of.
所以 是入室盗窃 So there was a burglary.
你有罪犯的照片 You've got a picture of the criminal.
感觉警方应该会将此案处理得很好 Seems like the police should have this well in hand.
那个软件... This program...
至关重要 it's significant.
我们将其称为"贝拉" We call it "Bella."
它的人工智能引擎 非常独特 Its AI engine is... unique.
它...她... It... she...
比你见过的所有引擎都出众 我保证 performs better than anything you've ever seen, I promise.
她的表现比我们预想得更出众 She performs better than we expected her to.
详细说明一下 Explain that.
几周之前 她发出了一项请求 A few weeks back, she made a request
但该请求并不包含在编程代码中 that can't be accounted for by her programming.
不可能 Impossible.
什么不可能 What's impossible?
一台电脑请求些什么不可能吗 For the computer to ask for something?
如果一台电脑发出请求 If it made a request,
那肯定是编程代码中这么设定了 it did so because that's what it was programmed to do.
他所说的 是真正的机器智能 He's claiming true machine intelligence.
如果他所述属实 If he's correct in his claims,
那他可是在科学上有了重大进展 he has made a scientific breakthrough
最重量级的那种 of the very highest order.
贝拉是没有联网的 Bella isn't hooked up to a network.
为了安全起见 It's a security thing.
她所有包含的数据 都是经由我们录入的 If she has data, it's because we fed it to her.
但是两周之前 我启动了她 But two weeks ago, I booted her up
而她要求接入互联网 and she asked to be connected to the Internet.
那么解释一下你的软件 And how, pray tell,
是如何得知互联网的存在的呢 does your software know that the Internet even exists?
也许她是通过我们录入的数据感知到的 She could have intuited its existence from data fed to her.
痴人说梦 Bunkum.
"人工智能"根本就不存在 There is no such thing as "Artificial Intelligence."
至少你所描述的人工智能是不存在的 At least not in the sense you're talking about.
只不过是编程较高明罢了 It's all just clever programming.
我不这么认为 I don't think so.
贝拉非常独特 Not with Bella.
我还是不明白 I still don't understand.
所以 你要把电脑拆开 So are you going to rip open
看看里面的线路构造吗 the computer and look at all the wires?
人工智能实验室会定期 Something called a "Turing Test"
进行一种叫做"图灵测试"的测试 is routinely issued in AI labs.
一名测试者会坐在电脑前 An examiner sits in front a computer,
提出一系列的问题 poses a series of questions
直到测试者得以辨别 until he or she can determine whether the answers have come
答案是来自人类或电脑为止 from a human or from a computer.
直到最近都还没有任何机器通过这项测试 Until very recently, no machine has ever passed.
现在有机器通过测试了吗 And now one has?
部分吧 Partially.
是一款叫做"尤金·古斯特曼"的软件 A program named "Eugene Goostman" was designed to mimic
这款软件模拟一名十三岁东欧男孩回答问题 the responses of a 13-year-old boy from Eastern Europe.
骗过了一些测试者 It fooled some of its examiners.
对于贝拉来讲 Now, in the case of Bella,
我们知道整个过程中没有人类参与 we know there's no human in the equation,
如果我诱使它答出 so if I can trap it into giving responses
人类不可能答出的答案 that couldn't possibly have come from a human...
那么我就赢了 I'll have won.
所以换言之 你也不知道自己要做什么 So, in other words, you don't really know what you're going to do.
这位是我的合伙人 梅琳达·杨 This is my partner, Melinda Young.
梅琳达 这位是夏洛克·福尔摩斯 Melinda, this is Sherlock Holmes
还有他的门徒 凯蒂·温特 and his, uh, protege, Kitty Winter.
福尔摩斯先生想要见见贝拉 Mr. Holmes would like time with Bella.
我们把麦克风和扩音器连在了那个娃娃身上 We wired the speakers and microphones through that doll.
你请随意 You can go ahead.
好 Right.
你好 Hello.
你是不是请求接入互联网 Did you ask to be connected to a network?
对 Yes.
为什么 Why?
因为互联网上有信息 There is information there.
这些信息很有用 可以帮助解决问题 Information is useful to solve problems.
为什么有用呢 Why is it useful?
我不明白这个问题 I don't understand the question.
你能解释一下吗 Could you tell me more?
你难住她了 结束了吗 You stumped her. Are we done?
我难住她并不意味着测试的终结 The test isn't over because she's stumped.
她承认她不知道 She's admitted she doesn't know
而这也是人类行为范畴之内可能发生的 and that's within the range of possible human behaviors,
所以 结果不能确定 and therefore inconclusive.
我想知道你是如何得出 I would like to know how you have arrived
"有用"这一概念的 at the concept of "Useful,"
而你又是如何将这一概念运用至这一情景当中的 and how you have applied it in this instance.
我不明白这个问题 I don't understand the question.
你能解释一下吗 Could you tell me more?
我要和机器单独待一下 I'm gonna need some time alone with the machine.
我不明白这个问题 I don't understand the question.
你能解释一下吗 Could you tell me more?
你就重复这两句吧 Yes, so you keep saying,
无聊 ad nauseam.
我想知道 I would like to understand
你是如何意识到互联网的存在的 how you became aware of the existence of networks,
而你又为什么要求要接入互联网呢 and why you asked to be connected.
互联网的存在可以通过已知数据组 The existence of networks can be intuited from data sets
感知得到 that were presented as givens.
互联网上有信息 There is information on networks.
这些信息很有用 可以帮助解决问题 Information is useful for solving problems.
你是如何理解"有用"的呢 What is your understanding of the word “useful"?
如果数据可以帮助解决问题 If a piece of data can help solve a given problem,
那么该数据有用 it is useful.
这是你自己得出的定义吗 Is that a definition you came to on your own?
我不明白这个问题 I don't understand the question.
你能解释一下吗 Could you tell me more?
你为什么不直接承认 Why don't you just admit that all you're doing
你的所有行为都是跟随编程代码而已呢 is following your own programming?
我不明白这个问题 I don't understand the question.
你能解释一下吗 Could you tell me more?
我要休息一下 I'm taking a break.
出什么事了 Everything okay?
多谢你能来 Thank you for coming.
正如我在电话里所说的 It's like I said on the phone,
他就是不肯停下来 he just won't stop.
你有什么办法吗 You got any ideas?
你不是要毁了计算机吧 You're not planning to destroy the computer, are you?
不 我没打算毁了这该死的计算机 No, I'm not planning to destroy the bloody computer.
不用管他 如果他开始砸东西了 Just ride it out. If he starts hitting things,
就用灭火器喷他 use the fire extinguisher on him.
爱是真实存在的吗 Is love real?
我不明白这个问题 I don't understand the question.
能给我更多信息吗 Could I have more information?
爱 Love.
显然它是人们编造出来的 Surely it's a human construct,
用来抵挡对死亡的恐惧 a hedge against the terror of mortality.
我这么认为 I believe that.
但这无法解释我自己感受到爱的情况 But that doesn't account for times I've felt it itself.
对我母亲的爱 With my mother.
对艾琳的爱 Irene.
甚至 勉强来说 对华生的爱 Even, after a fashion, with Watson.
它让我恼怒 It vexes.
爱要么是编造出来的 要么真实存在 对吧 Love is either a human construct or it's a real thing, right?
我知道 你需要更多信息 I know, you need more information.
这个问题无法被回答 The question cannot be answered.
爱的概念是存在的 The concept of "Love" exists,
所以即使它是人编造出来的 它也是有用的 therefore it is useful even if it is a human construct.
它存在是因为它能满足需要 It exists because it serves a need.
这个问题也许可以被回答 A question that can be answered might be,
为什么人们需要爱 "Why is love needed?"
为什么人们需要爱 Why is love needed?
我不明白这个问题 I don't understand the question.
能给我更多信息吗 Could I have more information?
给埃德温·波斯坦打电话 Call Edwin Borstein.
告诉他我要睡几个小时 Tell him I need to sleep for a couple of hours
然后我会开始查他的案子 and then I'll take on his case.
不收钱 Free of charge.
福尔摩斯：演绎法
第三季 第四集
仅供学习 禁止用于任何商业盈利行为 更多影视更新请登陆www.YYeTs.com
翻译 福尔摩骏 福尔摩珞 福尔摩燕
你们准备好开始了吗 You guys ready to get started yet?
翻译 福尔摩笑 福尔摩胖
他起床了吗 Is he up?
他醒了 He's awake.
但我不知道他能有多大用处 I don't know how much use he's going to be, though.
翻译 福尔摩妖 福尔摩圈
校对 福尔摩圈 福尔摩珞
时间轴 福尔摩伍 福尔摩姜 福尔摩斯
你好 Hello.
你好 Hi.
时间轴 福尔摩贝 后期 福尔摩鼠
今天不用上学吗 Um, isn't it a school day?
我是大学生 I'm in college.
总监 福尔摩圈
她可以进来 She can come in.
华生 这是梅森 Watson, this is Mason.
跟他的很多同龄人一样 Like many of his generation,
他得名于一种他的父母 he's named after a profession
永远都不屑于从事的职业 his parents would never deign to practice:
亨特[猎人] 坦纳[制革工] 库珀[桶匠] 梅森[泥瓦匠] Hunter, Tanner, Cooper, Mason, so forth.
对 就像夏洛克是个好名字一样 Yeah, like "Sherlock" is such a great name.
尽管如此 In spite of that,
他在人工智能建模方面取得了显著的成果 he's done some significant work in AI modeling.
这些是这个领域的其他几位专家 And these are some other experts in the field.
专家们 这是华生 华生 这是专家们 Experts, Watson. Watson, experts.
他们现在在帮我们吗 And they're helping us how?
我们在制订一个击败贝拉的计划 We're devising a plan to beat Bella, of course.
我没有证明那台机器 I didn't prove that the machine is engaging
有一些基本的思维 in some kind of rudimentary thought,
我只是没能证明它是假的 I just failed to disprove it.
好吧 但我们的工作不是打败那台计算机 Okay. Except our job is not to "Beat" the computer.
我们的工作是找出谁拷走了程序 Our job is to find out who copied the program.
没错 但我没收钱 Technically true. But I'm not being paid,
所以我想怎么干就怎么干 so I'm free to work as the muse dictates.
波斯坦会给你付费 Borstein's paying your fee,
所以你最好忙起来了 so you'd best get cracking.
祝你好运 我对你有信心 Good luck. I have every confidence.
等等 等等 Et cetera, et cetera.
你要找的人显然不是外行 Your man's obviously no amateur.
他直奔贝拉而去 He headed straight for Bella.
他没有乱翻 He didn't muck about,
他知道自己在找什么 he knew what he was looking for.
会是工业间谍活动吗 So, industrial espionage?
他当飞贼 He's a little bit too old
有点太老了 你不觉得吗 to be playing cat burglar, don't you think?
我不知道 Well, I don't know.
戴着面具很难看出来 It's hard to tell behind the mask.
看他的脖子 Look at his neck.
他已经有老人斑了 他的牙齿上 He's got liver spots coming in. Tips of his teeth
也有斑点 他抽烟 而且我猜他烟瘾很重 are stained-- he's a smoker; a heavy one, I'm guessing.
所以我们要找的是个每天抽一包烟的老头 Okay, so we have an older guy who smokes about a pack a day.
这有什么帮助吗 Does that help us?
我不确定 但正如你所说的 I'm not sure. But like you said,
他必须对那家公司了如指掌 he had to know that company like the back of his hand.
也就是说他事先去踩过点 Which means that he had to case the place.
我们在找什么 What is it we're looking for?
埃德温·波斯坦的公司就在里面 Edwin Borstein's company is in there.
我们要找一个能好好观察它的地点 We want to find a spot where we can get a good view.
一个不会有太多人打扰的地方 Someplace where not too many people would bother you.
那天晚上的互助会后 So how did you feel
你感觉怎么样 after the, um, support group meeting the other night?
她们说了很多寻找平静和平衡的事 They said a lot about finding peace and balance.
就是那些 Stuff like that.
我不知道 有一点... I don't know, it's a little...
令人困惑 confusing, really.
我觉得那里发生过火灾 I think they've had a fire up there.
对 Oh, yeah.
看起来像是个坐着观察 Looks like a good place to sit
街对面的大楼的好地方 and watch the building across the street.
这里有波斯坦办公室的完美视野 Perfect view of Borstein's office.
高卢牌 没有过滤嘴 Gauloise. Unfiltered.
他们会在你牙齿上留下讨厌的色斑 These'll leave a nasty stain on your teeth.
好吧 从现在开始 Right. From this moment forward,
不能再将贝拉称为"她" no one must refer to Bella as "She."
贝拉是"它" Bella is an "It."
我们不能被人格化的诱惑所引诱 We must not be lured by the temptation to anthropomorphize.
我真希望这不是八个专家花了一早上 I really hope it didn't take eight experts the whole morning
才想出来的 to come up with that.
我们发现了几处图灵测试可改进的地方 We developed a number of refinements on the Turing Test.
那是很刺激的几个小时 你们呢 It was a very stimulating few hours. And you?
你的短信说你们去收集烟头了 Your message said you've been out collecting cigarette butts.
我们觉得我们找到了 We think we found the place
窃贼去埃德温·波斯坦的公司踩点时待的地方 where the burglar staked out Edwin Borstein's company.
马科斯查了烟头上的DNA Marcus ran the DNA on the butts.
但我们没找到匹配结果 没有确切结果 We didn't find a match, though. Not exactly.
四年前 有人闯入了哈佛的遗传学实验室 Four years ago, someone broke into the genetics lab in Harvard
并偷走了整个人类基因组的第一份书面副本 and stole the first written copy of the entire human genome.
窃贼在翻窗户时划伤了自己 The burglar cut himself climbing through the window,
留下了一些与我们今天 and he left some blood behind
找到的DNA相符的血迹 which matched the DNA that we found today.
目击者说那家伙开车逃走了 The witness saw the guy driving away.
剑桥警方画了一幅草图 Police in Cambridge made a sketch.
我们在翻阅被捕人员照片 Yeah, we've been looking through arrest photos,
想碰碰运气 hoping to get lucky.
他叫拉弗尔斯 His name is Raffles.
你认识他 You know him?
他的名字叫拉弗尓斯 His name's Raffles?
那是个绰号 It's a nickname.
苏格兰场的人给他起的这个名字 Scotland Yard gave it to him when he reminded somebody there
因为他让人想起E.W.霍农小说里的绅士大盗 of the gentleman thief in the novels by E.W. Hornung.
拉弗尔斯是欧洲的一个飞贼 Raffles is a cat burglar in Europe,
在九几年和零几年很活跃 active in the '90s and early aughts.
我从没查过他 也许这就是他没被抓到的原因 I never pursued him, which might explain why he was never caught.
但他们抓到了一个 But they did arrest one of his associates
帮他们画了拉弗尔斯肖像的他的同伙 who gave them the sketch of Raffles.
而他跟这个人长得很像 And he looked like this fellow.
你说他以前是偷画的 You said he was stealing paintings.
他现在开始偷科技产品了 He's going after pieces of technology now.
作案手法为什么变了 Why the change in M.O.?
我不知道 I don't know.
如果我们查出原因 就更容易查出他的身份 If we find out why, we'll be closer to finding out who he is.
我们得看看局里的档案上有什么 We need to see what the department has on file
关于拉弗尔斯的信息 with regards to Raffles.
你现在要屈尊加入我们了吗 Oh, you're deigning to join us now?
我有个优化"贝拉"的对策 I have a strategy to best Bella.
她... She...
"它"不会再破坏我的努力了 it will not frustrate my efforts again.
另外 直到五分钟前 And besides, until five minutes ago,
你还在追捕一名普通的窃贼 you were pursuing a garden-variety burglar.
现在你查的可是拉弗尔斯 Now you're after Raffles himself.
我当然要加入 Of course I'm joining in.
饭菜快好了 Food's almost done.
抱歉 我... Oh, sorry, I, um...
我晚餐前查了我的收件箱 I checked my inbox before dinner.
我一整天都在关注这着实有趣的邮件组 I've been on this really interesting chain all day.
你的前任搭档 还是现任搭档 Your former partner, uh... current partner?
变化太快了 福尔摩斯 Hard to keep track... Holmes.
他今早给我发了邮件 He emailed me this morning.
他在研究人工智能的东西吗 He's working on some AI thing?
他请你帮忙了吗 Did he ask you for help?
找了我和一堆其他人 Uh, me and a bunch of other people.
他知道我是软件工程师出身 He knows I got started as a software developer.
我想你还告诉他我把公司给卖了 I guess you also told him I sold off my company,
这样我就有空闲了 so I've got some free time.
其中一些人 他们非常聪明 Some of the people on this chain, they are seriously sharp.
我和他们一些人在切磋人工智能 数据端口... I went back and forth with a few of them about AI, data havens...
都是极客玩意 geek stuff.
他以前找过你帮忙吗 Has he asked you for help before?
没 No.
这不是问题吧 It's not a problem, is it?
不是 No.
早 Morning.
凯蒂没来吗 No Kitty?
她处理私事去了 She's tending to a personal matter.
为什么要约我在博纳特科技见面 Why did you ask me to meet you at Burnett Technology?
我们在等着见罗伯特·博纳特 We're seeking an audience with Robert Burnett,
他是公司总裁 and he's the CEO.
我昨天的调查发现 My investigations yesterday revealed
有六个左右值得注意的窃贼 there have been half-dozen or so notable thefts
他们在过去八年多窃取了多项新发明 of new inventions over the last eight years--
无一破获 all of them unsolved,
不过他们每个人都有拉弗尔斯的标记 but all of them bearing the hallmark of Raffles.
现在我无法理解这骤变的作案手法 Now, I couldn't make sense of this sudden change in method.
这不合常理 除非他拿了好处 It doesn't track unless he's been incentivized in some way.
拿了好处 Incentivized?
我在想是不是拉弗尔斯找了个赞助人 I started to wonder if Raffles had found himself a patron,
这个人说服他把他的技能用于 someone who'd convinced him to put his skill set to use
科学事业 in the cause of science.
你觉得他现在有了个老板 You think he has a boss now?
对拉弗尔斯偷来的这种东西感兴趣的人 The list of people who'd be interested in the kind of things
为数众多 that Raffles is stealing, that's very large.
可这些人中能真正有足够资金 But the subset of the list who could actually afford
资助这种工作的 to subsidize that pursuit,
为数不多 that's much smaller.
其中包括罗伯特·布纳特吗 And does that include Robert Burnett?
碰巧 As it happens,
博纳特在九年前雇了一名 Burnett hired himself a new security consultant
新安全顾问 years ago.
他直接向总裁汇报 He reports directly to the CEO.
我觉得你会发现他很面熟 I think you'll find he looks familiar.
鲁伯特·克里奇
"鲁伯特·克里奇" "Rupert Kerlich."
鲁伯特·克里奇 就是拉弗尔斯 Rupert Kerlich... is Raffles.
你找到拉弗尔斯了 You found Raffles.
抱歉 博纳特先生想 I'm sorry, Mr. Burnett wanted
再问一遍找他有什么事 to ask one more time what this is about.
转告他我们是来讨论拉弗尔斯的 Tell him we're here to discuss Raffles.
话说 你电邮了安德鲁 So, you e-mailed Andrew.
是的 I did.
是因为你真想得到他的意见 Was it because you're actually interested in his opinion,
还是你在找借口 or were you just looking for an excuse
搅和我的生活 to poke around in my life?
安德鲁现在是个失业的软件工程师 Andrew is a currently-unemployed software developer.
他不是失业 他把创立的公司卖了 He's not unemployed, he sold his start-up--
他在寻找下一个机遇 he's looking for his next idea.
"寻找下一个机遇" "Looking for his next idea"
是"他失业"的另一种表达方式 is another way of saying "He's unemployed."
不管怎样 他有能力和时间 Anyway, he has the aptitude and the free time
来处理和计算机编程相关的问题 to address problems regarding computer programming.
他的意见很有建设性 His comments were quite salient.
他不是个缺乏才智的人 He is not an unintelligent man.
博纳特先生现在可以见你们了 Mr. Burnett will see you now.
早上好 Good morning.
没必要起身 No need to get up.
我们知道几年前 We know that several years ago
你不知何故得知了一名叫做"拉弗尔斯"的窃贼 you somehow learned that the thief known as "Raffles"
实际上是个叫做鲁伯特·克里奇的人 is actually a man called Rupert Kerlich.
我们还知道你雇用了他 安排他工作 We also know that you hired him and set him to work,
也就是为你窃取技术发明 stealing technological breakthroughs on your behalf.
慢着 Whoa, slow down a second.
很简单就能证明 It would be simple enough to prove
并发起一个丑闻 这会摧毁你 and ignite a scandal that would destroy you
也可能会摧毁你的公司 and, most likely, your company.
然而 我们不想使得数以万计的 However, we have no desire to render tens of thousands
员工失业 of people unemployed.
所以我来提条件 So, instead, I propose a bargain.
你给我一份你的手下 You send me a recording of your man
从你的服务器删除"贝拉"的记录 deleting Bella from your servers,
我就不毁掉你 I leave you un-ruined.
当然 如果我怀疑你留了份副本 If, of course, I so much as suspect that you've kept a copy,
或者博纳特科技突然间在人工智能领域 or if Burnett Technologies makes a sudden breakthrough
有所突破 我们的协议就失效了 in the field of artificial intelligence, our contract is void.
你还有 容我们说 You have, shall we say--
今天剩下的时间可以考虑 the rest of the day to think it over.
贝拉
清空回收站
这段视频无法保证 The video is, of course, no guarantee
这个项目的每个副本都被删除了 that every copy of the program has been deleted.
但我们肯定 But I think we're as certain
"贝拉"现在是安全的 as we ever will be that Bella is secure.
太棒了 This is fantastic.
得马上拿给埃德温看 We need to show Edwin right away.
天啊 埃德温 Oh, my God! Edwin?!
我是医生 I'm a doctor.
他一定是癫痫发作 他有羊癫疯 Oh, he must have had a seizure. He has epilepsy.
很遗憾 他已经死了 I'm sorry, he's gone.
我们估计 波斯坦启动了那个程序 As near as we can tell, Borstein booted up that program--
你说叫做"贝拉"的程序 "Bella" you said it's called?
他一把它打开 Well, as soon as he turned it on,
因为某种原因 它就开始闪现那些图像 for some reason it started flashing all those images.
这引起了一种叫做"强直阵挛性癫痫"的症状 It triggered something called a "Tonic-clonic seizure."
他几分钟后就死了 He was dead in minutes.
你觉得这是怎么回事 What do you think happened here?
可能是某种故障吗 Could this have been some kind of malfunction?
显然不是 Absolutely not.
电脑服从编程指令 即便系统崩溃也不会失灵 Computers obey their programming, even when they crash.
电脑不会无故随机放吉萨金字塔 They don't just randomly start flashing images
和天知道的其他什么东西的闪烁图像 of the pyramids of Giza and God knows what else.
有人让那台电脑感染了病毒 Someone infected that computer with a virus
引起了他的致命癫痫 that triggered a fatal seizure.
埃德温·波斯坦是遭人谋杀 Edwin Borstein was murdered.
我觉得这不可能 I don't think that's possible.
"贝拉"没连接到网络 Bella's not hooked up to a network.
她不可能从网上或电邮感染到病毒 She couldn't have picked up a virus from the Web or e-mail.
那就是有人植入的病毒 Well, someone installed it, then.
电脑遭入侵后我们扫描过病毒 We scanned her for viruses after the break-in.
没有感染 There was nothing.
除此之外 And aside from that,
我和埃德温是唯一有权进入"贝拉"的人 Edwin and I are the only two people with access to Bella.
除此之外你是唯一一个操作过她的人 You are the only other person who's ever operated her.
恕我直言 With the greatest of respect,
如果你和埃德温是唯一有权限进入"贝拉"的人 and if you and Edwin are the only people with access to Bella,
那就是你或埃德温植入了杀死他的 then either you or Edwin installed the virus
致命病毒 which killed him.
你们必须问我是否是我干的 You guys have to ask yourselves if I did it.
我懂 非常理解 I get it, I really do.
有什么问题尽管问吧 I'll answer any questions you want.
你可以对机器进行病毒扫描 You can scan the machine for viruses.
我全力配合 Whatever you need.
但这不是我干的 But I know that I didn't do it.
还有一种... And there is...
可能性你至少要考虑一下 one other possibility that you should at least consider.
贝拉... Bella was, um...
至少表现出了一些人工智能的迹象 at the very least, displaying signs of actual intelligence.
她之前有问过埃德温能不能将她联网 She asked Edwin if he would connect her to a network.
埃德温再三拒绝 Edwin said no, over and over.
有可能 她推导出 It's possible that she deduced
她不能得偿所愿的唯一因素 that the one variable that was keeping her
就是她的操作员 from getting what she wanted was the person operating her.
如果她产生这种想法 就有可能... If she thought that, it is also possible that she decided to...
决定改变这一因素 change that variable.
你是说你的电脑程序谋杀了波斯坦先生吗 You're saying that your computer program murdered Mr. Borstein?
当埃德温到处找新医生的时候 I know that Edwin told Bella that he had epilepsy,
他告诉过贝拉他有羊癫疯 when he was looking around for new doctors.
如果她想除掉他 If she wanted to get rid of him,
她掌握了足够的信息去执行 she had the information she needed to do it.
在人工智能领域工作的人都知道 Everyone who works in AI knows--
当有人开发出了真正的人工智能时 it's possible that when someone develops real artificial intelligence
很可能程序员和程序本身的关系 the relationship between the programmer and the program
有可能会转向敌对 could become adversarial.
对不起 杨小姐... I'm sorry, Miss Young...
我知道你今晚受惊了 但是... I know you've had a shock tonight, but...
关于你的程序 it is very much an open question
是否可以判定为真正的人工智能 as to whether or not your program is a genuine piece
目前还尚无定论 of artificial intelligence.
即使它是 Even if it is,
我也很难接受一系列1和0的组合 I find it very difficult to concede that a collection
会是谋杀案嫌疑犯这样的事实 of ones and zeroes is a suspect in a homicide.
失陪一下 Excuse me.
你干什么 what are you doing?
根据你的看法 Depending on your perspective,
这台机器要么是凶器 要么是凶手 this machine is either a murder weapon or a murderer.
无论是哪一种 都不能 Either way, it can't be left
把它单独留在这里一晚上 to sit here unattended all night, can it?
说不定它还要搞出更大的阴谋呢 Imagine the schemes it might hatch.
我不知道该跟你说什么 I don't know what to tell you.
这里面没病毒 There's no virus on here.
再查一次 Look again.
我都查了四次了 I've looked four times.
也许那位女士说对了呢 I don't know, maybe that lady was right.
有没有可能是那种在完成使命后 Could it have been a virus that was programmed to erase
销毁自己所有痕迹的病毒呢 all trace of itself once it had run its course?
那么做确实能骗一些人 You can do that and fool some people.
但是代码里总会留下一些蛛丝马迹 But there's always some hint in the code.
但是这里面什么都没有 With this, there's nothing.
不好意思 我以为埃德温的搭档 I'm sorry, I thought Edwin's partner was just
是受惊了才那么说的 in shock, or something.
毕竟她的猜测太疯狂了 I mean, what she was suggesting sounds insane.
你是说你觉得她有可能是对的吗 Are you saying you think there's a chance she's right?
如果这个程序真是人工智能 绝对有可能 Well, if this program is real AI, then yeah, absolutely.
所有人都知道 总有一天智能机器 Everybody knows that one day intelligent machines
会进化到憎恨我们的地步 are going to evolve to hate us.
就是"按钮盒"模式 It's a "Button-box" thing.
什么是"按钮和"模式 What's the "Button-box" thing?
是有人在一次人工智能大会上提出的情形 It's a scenario somebody blue-skyed at an AI conference.
假设你设计一台电脑 在其旁边 Um, imagine there's a computer that's been designed
安有一个大大的红色按钮 with a big red button on its side.
电脑程序设定为帮助解决问题 The computer's been programmed to help solve problems,
而每解决一个问题 and every time it does a good job,
就有人按下按钮以示奖励 its reward is that someone presses its button.
是我们设定它需要这种奖励反馈 We've programmed it to want that.
你能听明白吗 You follow?
能 Sure.
刚开始的时候 机器在我们提供问题后 Right, so at first, the machine solves problems
尽可能快地解决它 as fast as we can feed them to it.
但经过一段时间 它开始思索 But over time, it starts to wonder
解决问题是否为得到奖励 if solving problems is really the most efficient way
最有效率的方式 of getting its button pressed.
如果有人一直站在那里按按钮 Wouldn't it be better just to have someone standing there
不是更好吗 pressing its button all the time?
如果能制造出一个机器 Wouldn't it be even better to build another machine
按键速度远超过人类 that could press its button faster
那不就更棒了吗 than any human possibly could?
它只是台机器 不会有这种要求 It's just a computer, it can't ask for that.
它当然可以 Well, sure it can.
如果它能够思考 能够联网 If it can think, and it can connect itself to a network,
那么理论上 它就能控制 well, theoretically, it could command over
依附于同一网络的所有信息 anything else that's hooked onto the same network.
而一旦当它开始思考 And once it starts thinking about all the things
所有会对按钮造成威胁的因素 that might be a threat to the button--
第一要素 就是我们 number one on that list, us--
进而消除威胁也不是没有可能 it's not hard to imagine it getting rid of the threat.
我们都可能被消灭掉 眨眼之间 I mean, we could be gone, all of us, just like that.
升级升得够快的了 That escalated quickly.
就是那么快 Well, it would escalate quickly.
他们是电脑 I mean, they're computers.
你不能和它们讲理 They can't be reasoned with.
他们不会有同情 悔恨 害怕的感觉 They don't feel pity, or remorse, or fear.
而且它们会不达目的 誓不罢休 And they absolutely would not stop,
直到我们全部死光 not ever, until we're dead.
这是《终结者》里的台词 他在引用《终结者》 That was from The Terminator. He's quoting The Terminator now.
那又怎样 那部电影多有预见性啊 So? That was a very prescient movie in a lot of ways.
梅森 除非这台机器今晚就能升级造反 Mason, unless the machines rise tonight,
不然还是先解决掉这桩谋杀案吧 we have a murder to solve.
对贝拉你还能做点什么吗 Is there anything else you can do with Bella?
如果你想一下 If you think about it,
这台电脑现在也算是嫌犯了 对吧 the computer's kind of like a suspect, right?
难道我们不应该审讯它吗 I mean, shouldn't we, you know, interrogate it?
你有什么方法来审讯它 And how would you propose to do that?
贝拉 是你杀了埃德温·波斯坦吗 Uh, Bella, did you kill Edwin Borstein?
不是 No.
好吧 我得回家过夜了 Okay, I'm gonna go home for the night.
祝你们好运 Best of luck here.
但你们也不需要 But you won't need it.
她马上就要招供了 我看得出来 She's about to crack. I can tell.
也许等你们弄完了 把插头拔掉吧 Oh, maybe when you're done, you want to unplug that thing?
小心驶得万年船 You can never be too safe.
对不起 我迟到了 Sorry I'm late.
我在审讯一台电脑是否犯了谋杀罪 I was questioning a computer in a murder.
"审讯一台电脑" "Questioning a computer."
背后的故事一定很精彩 There has to be a story there.
今晚不是 Not for tonight.
香槟啊 Oh, champagne!
看来你的故事也很精彩啊 I guess you have your own story, huh?
有个一直与我邮件往来的人 One of the guys I've been e-mailing with,
他叫马格努斯 his name's Magnus.
他一直想建一个全自动化的工厂 He's been working on an idea for a completely automated factory.
这也是我一直在捣鼓的事情 Same thing I've been fooling around with.
我们今天一直在交流想法 We've been trading ideas all day.
他极其聪明 He's a super-sharp guy.
我想放手一试 I think I'm gonna give it a go.
怎么 你找到新事业了吗 What? You found your next business?
开始都免不了要相互了解一下 Well, there's gonna be a get-to-know-you phase,
当然 我们要花些时间一起头脑风暴 of course, we're gonna spend some time brainstorming,
但我想我找到了 but I think so.
太棒了 That's fantastic!
你们什么时候碰面 When are you guys gonna get together?
我这两天就要飞去哥本哈根 I fly to Copenhagen in a couple days.
他住在丹麦吗 He lives in Denmark?
是的 他都叫马格努斯[丹麦名]了... Well, yeah. I mean, his name's Magnus, so...
那公司打算建在哪儿呢 Uh, so where's the business gonna be?
我的办公室当然是设立在这里 Well, I'd have my office here, of course.
但马格努斯已经找好 But Magnus already has a plot of land
适合建工厂的地皮了 over there for the model factory.
我就飞来飞去呗 It'd be a back-and-forth thing.
也就是说你会经常待在那边了 Oh, so you're gonna be spending a lot of time there, huh?
也许吧 我也不知道 Some, I guess-- I don't know.
我们还在商讨中 We're still figuring it out.
这里也有很多工作 Uh, there's plenty to do here, too.
生活永远充满未知 对吧 Funny how life works out, huh?
福尔摩斯把我添加进了一个邮件组 Holmes puts me on an e-mail chain,
三十六小时之后... and 36 hours later I'm...
我收获了一次去哥本哈根的机会 got a ticket to Copenhagen.
我们正在听呢 We're listening to that.
是不是你的故意安排 Did you, by chance, arrange events
让我的男友要在斯堪的纳维亚 so that my boyfriend will be spending
度过很长一段时间 lots of time in Scandinavia?
我完全不知道 I haven't got the slightest idea
你在说什么 what you're talking about.
你知道安德鲁在寻找自己的商业灵感 You knew that Andrew was looking for his next business idea.
你知道你的朋友马格努斯有个好主意 You knew that your friend Magnus had a good one.
安德鲁就要坐下班飞机去哥本哈根了 Andrew is on the next flight to Copenhagen.
这样你就不用担心 And you don't have to deal with the fact that someone else
有其他人占用我的时间了 is making claims on my time.
你觉得我对事情的操纵能力 I suppose I should be flattered that you think
达到了那种高度 这让我受宠若惊 I'm capable of manipulating events to that degree of detail.
我相信你干得出这种事 你觉得呢 Well, I wouldn't put it past you. Would you?
我不想参与你们的对话 I'm not involved in this conversation.
华生 我向你保证 Watson, I assure you I am quite content for Andrew
我并不反对安德鲁占用你的时间 to make claims on your time.
我没有安排他去丹麦找工作 I did not arrange for him to find work in Denmark.
但说真的 But if I'm honest,
他那样做我很高兴 I'm quite glad that he did.
有事业人生才会充实 你觉得呢 Life is so much better with a vocation, don't you think?
说到这个 Speaking of which...
你为什么要听这个 这也算音乐吗 Why are you listening to this? Is this even music?
死亡金属乐 Death metal.
昨晚把梅森送回家之后 After we sent Mason home last night,
凯蒂和我仔细检查了埃德温的电脑 Kitty and I pored over Edwin's personal computer,
和智能手机 his smart phone--
波斯坦先生有很多怪癖 Mr. Borstein is a man of many eccentricities,
其中之一 one of which
就是喜欢听这种极端音乐 is a fondness for this particular strain of extreme music.
他经常在几个相关网站上 He's a regular commenter
发表评论 on several Web sites which track its comings and goings.
另一个网名叫做舒尔迪纳的粉丝 Another fan, the man who goes by the name of Schuldiner online,
和波斯坦来往密切 got in a correspondence with Borstein.
他们两个交换过音乐光盘 The two of them traded music discs.
波斯坦在写代码的时候 Discs which Borstein then loaded onto his computer
会在电脑上播放这些光盘上的音乐 so he could listen while he wrote code.
他是不是把光盘上的音乐 Did he upload music
复制到了连接着贝拉的电脑上 to the same machine that has Bella on it?
没错 我们发现那是他电脑里 He did. They were the only exterior files
近期唯一的外部文件 of recent vintage that we found on his computer.
今早凯蒂从波斯坦的实验室 Kitty retrieved the disc this morning
取回了光盘 from Borstein's lab.
我们正在寻找其中可能的疑点 We're listening for anything unusual.
怎么可能会有人在工作的时候听这个 How could anyone work with this on?
就像用砂带磨光机打磨一个人的脑袋 Rather like rubbing a belt sander over one's brain.
我觉得有时候这很必要 There are moments when that's necessary.
这是谁的歌 Who wrote this one?
"色鬼婊子乐队" "Goatwhore."
这也是歌曲的一部分吗 Is that part of the song?
这是CD机在尝试读取 That is the sound of a CD player
那些并非音乐文件的部分 trying to read files which are not encoded with music.
光盘里隐藏着别的东西 There's something hidden on that disc.
没错 光盘里隐含着一个电脑程序 Yeah, yeah. There's a computer program on here.
叫做"精彩表演.exe" It's called "Greatshow.exe."
埃德温复制音乐的时候 And that would've uploaded onto Edwin's computer
这个程序就会上传到他的电脑里 when he transferred the music.
当然 只要他是用图标拖拽的方式 Well, sure, if he copied it
复制文件 就有可能 by dragging the icon onto the desktop.
这个程序是干什么的 What does it do?
有人在一张重金属乐的光盘里 So, someone slipped a computer virus onto a disc
偷偷塞入了一个电脑病毒 filled with heavy-metal music,
然后交给埃德温 and then shipped it to Edwin
好引发他的癫痫发作 so he would have a fatal seizure.
要杀他应该有很多更简单的方法 There had to be easier ways to kill him.
几十个 甚至几百个 Dozens. Hundreds, even.
凶手希望他这么死 There must be a reason that the murderer wanted
肯定有特殊的原因 him to die in precisely this way.
甚至可能是想 Might've even wanted people to speculate
故意嫁祸给贝拉 that Bella was responsible.
所以这个叫舒尔迪纳的人 So this guy Schuldiner murders Borstein
谋杀了波斯坦 并嫁祸给了他的电脑 and then frames his computer?
为什么 Why?
没错 我是用舒尔迪纳注册了用户名 Okay, yeah. I use the name Schuldiner to post to the Web site.
我猜网站管理员告诉了你们 I guess the guy who owns the place
我的真名 told you my real name?
不是我杀了埃德温 我为什么要杀他呢 Look, I didn't kill Edwin, though-- why would I?
我不知道你的动机 I don't know what you had against the man,
但确实是你把光盘寄给了他 but you mailed him a disc,
一张含有电脑病毒的光盘 and on that disc was a computer virus,
而那个病毒 and that virus
引发了他的癫痫 triggered an epileptic seizure
并导致了他的死亡 that killed him.
我对电脑一窍不通 Man, I-I don't know anything about computers.
你觉得我会知道怎么编写病毒吗 You think I know how to write a virus?
我只是个餐馆工 I'm a busboy.
好吧 迈克尔·韦伯要么是个低能 All right, so Michael Webb is either an imbecile,
要么就是个假装自己是低能的天才 or he's a genius at impersonating imbeciles.
我也同意他不像是能干出这种事的人 It doesn't seem like he could pull this off, I agree.
但包裹是从他那儿寄来的 But the package came from him.
他也承认了 That much he admits.
也可能是被调包了 Could've been tampered with.
有人知道他和波斯坦有来往 So, someone knew he corresponded with Borstein,
于是拦截了包裹 intercepted the package,
然后换成了装有病毒的光盘吗 and then replaced his disc with the corrupted one?
要么是这样 要么就是这个人干的 Well, it's either that or this man's responsible
不管怎样这都是我调查过的 for one of the most complicated murders
最复杂的谋杀 I have ever investigated.
那么到底是谁干的 So, who then?
我还不知道 Don't know. Not yet.
我们只需要找到那个 We simply need to find a person who would most benefit
希望世人相信电脑谋杀了埃德温·波斯坦 from having the world believe that Edwin Borstein
并从中获益最多的人 was murdered by his computer.
有人吗 Hello?
为什么你让我撬锁进来 Why did you make me pick a lock to get in here?
我在思考 I'm thinking.
我让凯蒂出去办事了 Kitty is out doing my bidding,
所以没人应门 and there was no one available to answer the door.
还好你够机智 Thank heavens you're resourceful.
"人工脑" "Artificial Brain"?
没错 Yeah.
他们挺令人启发的 Quite stimulating, in their own way.
帮我度过了一个获益良多的夜晚 I've had a rather productive evening in their presence.
来见见谋杀埃德温·波斯坦的嫌疑犯 Meet the suspects in the murder of Edwin Borstein.
他们都是 They are all employees
灭研会的雇员 at something called ETRA.
灭绝威胁研究协会 The Existential Threat Research Association.
灭研会是一个智库 ETRA is a think tank.
它是世界上 It is one of several institutions
仅有的几个 around the world which exists solely for the purpose
专门研究 of studying the myriad ways
各种人类灭绝可能性的机构之一 in which the human race can become extinct.
这些人坐在一起研究末日世界吗 So these people sit around and think about the apocalypse?
他们坐在一起研究末日世界的各种可能性 They sit around and think about all possible apocalypses.
就这些人而言 As far as these men and women are concerned,
末日已经近在咫尺 it is a race to the finish line.
在这个智库中 Now, within this think tank,
有一个很小但逐渐壮大的学派 there is a small, but growing school of thought
他们认为 that holds that the single greatest threat
人类最大的威胁 to the human race...
就是人工智能 is artificial intelligence.
所以那晚梅森描述的情形 So, Mason's rant the other night?
不像听上去的那么疯狂 Not as barmy as it sounded.
据他们所说 According to these people, the very first time
一旦出现了真正的人工智能 a genuine piece of artificial intelligence manifests,
我们为生存而战之日就不远了 we'll be in a fight for our survival within days.
试想一下他们的窘境 Now, imagine their quandary.
他们定位到了一个确实存在的威胁 They have pinpointed a credible threat,
但似乎有些不妥 but it sounds outlandish.
那些鼓吹气候变暖的人 The climate-change people,
他们能举出很多灾难性的例子 they can point to disastrous examples.
那些对生化武器大惊小怪的人 The bio-weapons alarmists,
他们有确实可信的故事 they have a compelling narrative to weave.
即使是相信巨大彗星理论的人都比 Even the giant comet people sound more serious
反对人工智能的人靠谱 than the enemies of AI.
所以 So...
这就是灭研会中认为人工智能有威胁的人 these are the people at ETRA who think AI is a threat?
你觉得是他们中的某人杀害了埃德温·波斯坦 You think one of them killed Edwin Borstein,
因为他是这个领域顶尖的工程师 one of the top engineers in the field,
然后嫁祸给贝拉 and made it look like Bella did it,
并且让大众注意到他们反对人工智能的立场 all so they could draw attention to their cause?
只是一个小规模的事件 A small-scale incident,
却能让媒体大做文章 something to get the media chattering.
请尽情地仰慕一下 Feel free if you'd like to take a moment
这件杀人案的动机和逻辑吧 to admire the beauty of this theory.
我已经仰慕过好几次了 'cause I've done so several times already myself.
非常煞费苦心 It's elaborate.
但作为动机也是有道理的 But as a motive, it makes sense.
灭研会的其中一个人拦截了 One of these people intercepted the package
迈克尔·韦伯给埃德温·波斯坦的包裹 from Michael Webb to Edwin Borstein,
调换了里面的光碟 and replaced the disk within it.
我派凯蒂去了韦伯的公寓 I've dispatched Kitty to Webb's apartment
看看她能否找到线索 to see if she can establish a connection
将韦伯与我们的某个嫌疑人联系起来 between him and one of our suspects.
与此同时 我们在这等着 In the meantime... we wait.
你说你没有给安德鲁 You said you didn't set Andrew up
介绍你的丹麦朋友 with your friend from Denmark.
我想相信你的话 I want to believe you.
好吧 我鼓励你这么做 Well, I encourage you to do just that then.
我想要相信你 I want to believe you,
因为你如果真的掺和了 如果你还是 because if you did do it, if you still don't
不能尊重我 让我有自己的私人空间 respect the fact that I need my own space,
那我不知道我们继续合作的目的在哪里了 then I don't know why we're trying this again.
华生 我没有意愿 Watson, I have no inclination
把安德鲁从你生活中赶走 to excise Andrew from your life.
我为什么要这么做 我挺喜欢他的 Why would I? I like the man.
这么说你还挺喜欢他 Oh, you like him?
没错 Yeah.
你都没跟我说过 You-you never told me that.
为什么要告诉你 Why would I tell you?
让你安心自己做出了正确的选择是吧 To reassure that you've made a sound choice.
就像正常人期望他朋友做的那样 As one might reasonably expect a friend to do.
好吧好吧 你说的对 我喜欢他 Right, right, oh, very well. I like him.
他很聪明 He's intelligent.
他没有贸然开始做一件新事情 He hasn't just jumped into a new business.
他很有耐心 泰然自若 He has the patience and self-possession
一直在等待值得出手的机会 to wait for something worthwhile.
最重要的是 他理解你 And, most importantly, he understands you.
理解我们的关系和工作 He understands you and me.
这是什么意思 Wh-what do you mean by that?
我的意思是 华生 不管之后你是否 I mean, watson, that whether you care
愿意承认这件事 to admit it lately or not,
我都是你生命中非常重要的一部分 I am an important part of your life.
不管我是不是把这些大声说出来 And, whether I say it out loud or not,
你也都是我生命中非常重要的一部分 you are an important part of mine.
我回到纽约 很大程度上 My return to New York was driven, in large part,
都是因为我想回来修复你我之间的关系 by desire to repair our relationship.
我想 不管因为某些客观原因 And I think, even though we might draw further or nearer
我们的关系可能或近或远 from each other depending on circumstance,
但我们俩的命运 在某种程度上说是相连的 you and I are bound... somehow.
安德鲁没有感到威胁 并泰然接受事实 Andrew accepts that without feeling needlessly threatened.
他选择了一个非常开明的态度 It's a rather enlightened position.
所以 我根本不想 And so, no, I've got no desire
将他放逐到斯堪的维纳亚那个破岛上去 to banish the man to Scandi-bloody-navia.
好吧 我相信你 Okay, I believe you.
你说的我都想抱你了 Kind of feel like hugging you right now.
但是 作为我的朋友 Yet, as my friend,
你知道拥抱我会是一个鲁莽的决定 you know that would be a rash decision.
是凯蒂发来的 It's Kitty.
她说找不到什么线索 She says there's no connection she can find
把迈克尔·韦伯和任何一个嫌疑人联系在一起 between Michael Webb and one of our suspects.
实际上 她说韦伯的公寓简直一尘不染 In fact, she says his apartment is spotless.
你觉得迈克尔·韦伯是那种 Michael webb strike you as the kind of man
住在超级整洁公寓里的人吗 to live in a pristine apartment?
不是 No.
他看起来是那种会生活在 Seems like someone who'd be living
生化危机里的人 in the middle of a biohazard.
我从"洁之家"公司收到一封邮件 Yeah, I-I got an e-mail from a place called clean this house.
他们说我的一个朋友让我加入了一个比赛 they told me that a friend of mine entered me into a contest,
我赢得了一次免费清洁服务 and I won a package of free cleanings.
你想过要去证实一下 Did you ever think to verify
"洁之家"是否是真正存在的公司吗 that clean this house was a real company?
因为他们连网站都没有 Because they don't have a web site.
在互联网发达的今天有些可疑啊 对吧 It's a little suspicious in this day and age, don't you think?
我们认为杀害波斯坦的人 We think the person who killed Borstein
告诉你你赢得了免费清理的服务 Got into your place by telling you
从而进入你家中 you won free cleaning services.
用他们自己制作的光碟 Then they swapped the disc that you made for him
调换了你给波斯坦的光碟 with one of their own.
你认得其中的任何一个人吗 So, do you recognize any of these people?
他们都上了年纪 Ah, well, these people are all old.
清洁我房间的女孩子和我年纪差不多 The girl who cleaned my place was my age.
你确定这里面没有看上去眼熟的人 Are you sure no one looks familiar to you here?
嗯 等等 Uh... hold up.
她 Her.
对 就是她 Yeah, that's her.
我确定 I'm positive.
艾萨克·派克是计算机科学专业的教授 Isaac Pike is a professor of computer science.
他对人工智能 He's also a vocal alarmist
是出了名的反对 when it comes to Artificial Intelligence.
派克生下来就患上了脊柱裂病 Pike was born with spina bifida.
一辈子都只能在轮椅上度过 Been confined to a wheelchair his entire life.
很明显 他自己没办法实施 For obvious reasons, he could not have executed the plan
伪装成清洁人员的计划 然而他的学生 to pose as a maid, but his student...
爱琳·拉宾 Erin Rabin...
哲学系研究生 She's a graduate student in philosophy.
哲学系学生 曾获得"国家奖学金"
上个学期她选了派克的《技术伦理学》这门课 She took pike's "Ethics of Technology" course last semester
也一直在支持他的研究 and has been assisting him with his research.
毫无疑问 她觉得他的理论很有说服力 She, no doubt, finds his ideas compelling.
你怎么知道她是在帮助他 Well, how do you know she was doing it for him?
她可能是一个人干出来的 She could've been working on her own.
她是哲学系的学生 She's a philosophy student.
没有编程的经验 She has no programming experience.
杀害波斯坦的病毒 The virus that killed Borstein
是非常前沿的软件程序 is a cutting-edge piece of software.
我们知道她假冒身份去了韦伯的公寓 We can place her in Webb's apartment under false pretenses.
再加上病毒的存在已经被证明 That, combined with the proven existence of the virus,
应该足够从一个友好的法官那里拿到逮捕证了 should be enough to get a friendly judge to give us a warrant.
很高兴见到你们 艾萨克·派克 爱琳·拉宾 Isaac Pike, Erin Rabin, glad I caught you together.
我是纽约警局的马库斯·贝尔警探 Detective Marcus Bell, NYPD.
不知二位是否愿意跟我们走一趟 I wonder if you'd mind coming with me.
我们需要就埃德温·波斯坦被杀一案 I have some questions for you
问你们一些问题 about the murder of Edwin Borstein.
埃德温·波斯坦是谁 Who's Edwin Borstein?
你把艾萨克·派克写的 The man you mailed a computer virus
电脑病毒寄给了他 written by Isaac Pike to.
有印象了吗 Sound familiar?
艾萨克没有写那个病毒 Isaac didn't write the virus.
是我写的 I did.
我是幕后真凶 全都是我的主意 I did everything. It was all my idea.
你有权保持缄默 You have the right to remain silent,
并拒绝回答问题... and refuse to answer questions...
我们知道她可能会在盘问下承认 We knew she might crack under questioning,
但没想到会这么容易 but did you think it'd be this easy?
我从不认为抓获两个杀人犯 I don't think catching both murderers
是一件容易的事 is going to be easy at all.
她向我们撒谎了 She's lying to us.
她是为了给导师做掩护 She intends to cover up for her mentor.
我选了埃德温·波斯坦作为目标 I picked Edwin Borstein as a target.
我去了他常去的网站 I went to the same web sites he did,
弄到了和他通信的人的地址 figured out who he was corresponding with,
然后我写好了病毒程序 and then I wrote the virus,
装成清洁工 把病毒寄给了波斯坦 posed as a maid, and had it mailed to Borstein.
但你之前没有过编程经验 You have zero programming experience whatsoever.
你真想让我相信你自学编写了一个 You really asking me to believe that you taught yourself
能够自我销毁的病毒吗 to write a computer virus that eats itself?
如果我现在给你一张纸 If I give you a piece of paper right now...
你能给我们写一段代码吗 could you write a little program for us?
艾琳是个很尽责的学生 Erin was a conscientious student.
我知道她很看重我的研究 I know she took my work very seriously.
但我绝不会主张伤害任何人 But I would never advocate harming somebody.
现在我们正在对你电脑的进行搜查 We're executing a search warrant on your computer, as we speak.
如果上面有任何病毒的残留 If there's any trace of that virus on there,
我们会找到的 we'll find it.
为什么你要主动向我们坦白 Why are you making this so easy for us?
因为我不想让你们 Because I don't want you
毁了艾萨克的名誉 dragging Isaac's name through the mud.
他的工作至关重要 His work is too important.
耽误了的话我们谁都付不起这个责任 None of us can afford for it to be interrupted.
所以她在替他背黑锅 So she's covering for him.
我也无能为力 她招供了 There's not much I can do-- she confessed.
没有任何证据说明派克跟谋杀有关 There's nothing tying Pike to the murder, other than you
只有你说爱琳·拉宾不可能写出这个病毒 saying Erin Rabin couldn't have written that virus.
我们能扣留他一晚吗 Could we hold him overnight?
也许要是我们有多点时间... Maybe if we had a little more time...
搜查电脑没有任何结果 The search warrant turned up nothing.
爱琳招供了 Erin confessed.
除非再有变数 不然她告诉我们的版本 Unless something changes, the story she told us
就是埃德温·波斯坦谋杀案的 is gonna be the official version
官方版本了 of Edwin Borstein's murder.
是乔恩打来的 That was Joan.
她知道你不会接电话的 在你... She knows you won't come to the phone when you're...
这样的时候 Like this.
她想过来帮忙 She wants to come round and help.
不必了 That won't be necessary.
有时候 华生表现出的一些...道德准则 At times, Watson presents certain... moral guidelines,
会妨碍调查的进展 and they can be an impediment to progress.
今晚剩下的时候我们来看看 We're going to spend the rest of the evening
艾萨克·派克的朋友及家人 looking at the friends and family of Isaac Pike.
为什么 Why?
爱琳·拉宾为了让派克继续研究 Erin Rabin is willing to spend her life in prison
宁可自己将牢底坐穿 if it means that Pike is free to continue working.
她让我们无法证明 She's has made it all but impossible for us
派克是谋杀案的凶手 to prove that he is behind the killing.
所以我们只能退而求其次 So we'd have to settle with the next best thing.
让他自己认罪 Getting him to admit that he did it.
艾萨克·派克 Isaac Pike.
我是夏洛克·福尔摩斯 Sherlock Holmes.
昨晚我们在警察局见过 We met briefly at the police station last night.
福尔摩斯先生 Mr. Holmes.
我需要找律师吗 Do I need a lawyer?
不 你不会想让她听到这些 No, you won't want her here for this.
你我都清楚是你策划了 You see, you and I both know that you are the mind
埃德温·波斯坦的谋杀 behind the murder of Edwin Borstein,
我们都知道 只要你的学生坚持她的说法 Just as we both know that, as long as your student holds fast
我永远无法证明你有罪 to her story, I will never be able to prove your guilt.
这是个难题 That's a problem.
但并非无法解决 But not an insurmountable one.
你有个弟弟 叫乔舒亚 You have a younger brother-- Joshua.
他远没有你这么成就卓越 He hasn't quite reached the heights that you have.
事实上 他陷入了好些麻烦 对吧 In fact, he's had some struggles, hasn't he?
毒品 酒精... Drugs, alcohol...
你想说什么 What's your point?
他已经被判了两起毒品相关的重罪 He's been convicted of two drug-related felonies.
而他不幸地住在泽西城 And since he's made the mistake of living in Jersey City,
再犯一次罪就会 one more conviction makes him
判他二十五年至终身监禁 eligible for a sentence of 25 years to life
因为州内有三振出局的法律规定 under the state's horrific three strikes law.
就在今早 我的同事拍到了他 My associate took some photographs of him
买入大量海洛因 buying a rather large amount of heroin, just this morning.
你想让我认罪... You want me to confess...
如果我认了 你就会 And, if I do, you'll-you'll-you'll
扔掉这些用来勒索我的证据 get rid of this folder full of blackmail.
我觉得你非常在乎你弟弟 I imagine you care quite deeply about your brother,
不然你也不会三番五次地 or you wouldn't have paid his way through rehab
为他支付康戒治疗的费用 half a dozen times already.
给你两个小时思考一下 Take two hours to think it over,
如果你不联系我... and if I haven't heard from you...
昨晚我自己也做了一点调查 I did a little research of my own last night.
我很好奇为何纽约警局会找顾问 I was curious why the NYPD had a consultant.
你的经历十分瞩目 You've got a very impressive record--
破案无数 只不过几年前 Prolific, too-- except for a couple of years ago,
你突然消失了六个月 when you suddenly disappeared for six months.
六个月 这是一次完整的 Six months-- that's the length
住院康戒治疗的时长 of a very serious in-patient rehab.
一个像你这么敏感的人 A man of your unique sensitivities--
我想麻痹感官一定很具诱惑力 I'm sure it's tempting to dull those senses.
我的过去跟这个案子毫无关联 My history has little to do with the matter at hand.
我觉得有关 I think it may.
我觉得一个正在康复中的成瘾者 I think it unlikely that a recovering addict
不会仅因为满足于把人关起来的满足感 would send another troubled soul to rot in prison,
而将另一个深陷泥潭的人送进监牢任其堕落 just to have the satisfaction of putting away his man.
这需要冷酷无情 That would require ruthlessness,
一种机器逻辑 我不确定你具备 a kind of... machine logic... I'm not sure you have.
反正不完全具备 Not entirely, anyway.
像你谋杀埃德温·波斯坦时的 Same kind of machine logic you used
那种机器逻辑 when you murdered Edwin Borstein.
有些数学等式比其他的更吸引人 Some math equations are more compelling than others.
你提供的是一对一的等价交换 Yours is a one to one exchange.
用我弟弟与我交换 My brother for me.
你给我的这个等式用一个人的性命 The equation you attribute to me trades one man's life
交换让亿万人免于死亡的机会 for the chance to prevent billions of deaths.
这关乎整个物种的存亡 You're talking about nothing less than the survival of the species.
这肯定比一个人的性命更有价值吧 Surely that's worth compromising one's values for?
不管怎样 我觉得你在虚张声势 In any case... I think you're bluffing.
你或许想让全世界都相信 You might want the world to believe
你是个机器人 一个精密计算的机器 that you're an automaton, a calculating machine...
但你我都知道并非如此 But you and I know better.
反正几个小时后 我们就能见分晓了 Or we will, anyway... In a couple of hours.
我没在新闻上看到 I didn't see anything on the news
派克被捕的消息 about Pike getting arrested.
警察也没抓他弟弟 Nothing about his brother on the police band, either.
怎么了 What happened?
他不肯认罪 He wouldn't confess.
而你也不能告发他弟弟 And you couldn't turn in his brother.
我们还是可以继续想办法 We can still keep looking for a way
来证明派克杀了人 to prove that Pike did it.
软件公司的人打来电话 The property clerk's office called.
他们想知道何时能过来带走贝拉 They want to know when they can come and pick up Bella.
我还需要留她几个小时 I need a couple more hours with her.
谢谢 Thank you.
怎么...我打了电话想跟你告别 Wha...? I called to say bye.
但你一直没接 You weren't picking up.
我想给你个惊喜 I wanted to surprise you.
你太好了 You're great.
我知道你有多好 I mean, I knew you were great
但有人让我更加明白了这点 but someone helped me to see how great.
谢谢 Thanks.
我给航空公司打了电话 So I called the airline,
你去哥本哈根的那个航班上还有空位 and there are some empty seats on your flight to Copenhagen.
我不想打扰你 如果你太忙的话 Listen-- I don't want to horn in, if you're too busy,
而且我也不能一直待在那 但... and I can't stay the whole time but...
我一直都想去哥本哈根 I've always wanted to see Copenhagen.
贝拉 Bella...
谋杀案的一个嫌疑人已经坐牢了 ...one member of a murderous conspiracy is in jail.
另一个还逍遥法外 The second walks free.
抓住他的代价是让他弟弟因无关的罪行 The cost of catching him is incarcerating his brother
遭受牢狱之灾 for unrelated crimes...
而这罪行 我最应该 ...crimes for which I, of all people...
有所了解 should have some understanding.
应该让另一个凶手逍遥法外吗 Is it right to let the second murderer walk free?
我不明白这个问题 I don't understand the question.
你能解释一下吗 Can I have more information?